Internet
, 3 minute read

What if social media was just websites?

I’ve mentioned my dislike of social media a couple of times in the past. At the same time, I didn’t know what a good alternative would look like.

Social Media platforms all have the same few features that were introduced in a very different time. Nowadays these features are unhealthy. They exist for the sake of driving engagement and keeping people on the platform as long as possible. We measure ourselves based on views and likes and comments and engagement, even though we aren’t gaining anything from it. And new decentralized social media platforms just copied all the same outdated and bad features, with the promise that the people and their culture are different. But at the same time, many of our friends are not on there.

Today I had a thought: imagine a feed, swipeable like Reels or TikTok, but you’re swiping through a timeline of websites by your friends and other people you like to follow. A post may be a photo like on Instagram, a short video like Stories, a short text like a Tweet, a longer text like on a blog, news by an outlet you like to read, or any other unique way someone wants to express themselves. Each post is just a website.

This feed has no built-in likes or commenting system. Interactions can only happen inside your own content. You can add social features to your content, but you can also choose not to.

You can’t open this feed and add a post to it. It’s not a social media platform where you can post something. Your profile merely tracks who you’ve subscribed to, what you’ve already seen, and what’s new. It could even just run locally on your device.

To post, you can just host your own site. But you also don’t have to host your own stuff. Naturally, there could be hosting providers that work nicely with a feed. The feed and the hosts are two separate entities that can integrate nicely with each other through an open protocol. Like RSS but with a modern twist.

This open protocol can verify your identity. If you leave a comment or a like on a friend’s site, the feed reader passes your identity to the site, so you don’t have to log in and identify yourself before leaving a comment. If a friend’s content is private, the site can check if you’re allowed to view that content.

And it doesn’t need to be a single app that’s your feed reader. Since it’s an open protocol, everyone can try to build a better feed reader. Or a feed reader that’s only optimized for a specific kind of content, like photos on Instagram.

Does this already exist? Maybe ATProto, and I like the technical idea behind ATProto. However, ATProto standardizes data so that apps can present it however they want and with the social features they want. My take is to standardize discovery and identity, so publishers (you and I) can decide how they want to present their content and which social features they want to add. I don’t think we need a data protocol. We already have websites.

Today’s social media platforms make money by keeping people engaged. They control where we publish, how that content is distributed, and how other people consume it. In my alternative, these responsibilities are separated: Hosts compete by offering better publishing tools and customization, while feed readers compete by offering a better reading experience. When a host or feed reader optimizes too heavily for engagement, users can switch without losing the people they follow or their followers. These unhealthy features wouldn’t fully disappear, but we’re no longer locked into one definition of good social media.

It’s pure chaos. Different websites, different feeds, different ways of interacting. But maybe that’s a good thing. As argued in “Pray for Chaos”, the alternative to chaos isn’t necessarily something better.